Brother Against Brother: Violence and Extremism in Israeli Politics from Altalena to the Rabin Assassination

Front Cover
Simon and Schuster, 1999 - History - 366 pages
Although we in America may think that our political disputes are fierce, the fact remains that when we use the phrase "the crossfire," we generally mean it to be taken metaphorically. Not so in Israel, where national politics is contentious and, as Ehud Sprinzak reveals in his groundbreaking new book, where vehemence often spills over into violence. Sprinzak, one of Israel's most prominent and respected political scientists, lays bare the historical roots of violence in Israeli domestic politics, examining the effects such militancy has had on the nation's civic culture. He traces the origins of this extremist thread to the era of the founding of the Jewish state, and shows how it has grown increasingly malignant in the past decade, culminating in the 1995 assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin. Brother Against Brother takes the reader through the critical turning points of Israeli political history, and introduces us to the leaders whose careers were baptized by blood. In a masterful blending of narrative and historical analysis, Sprinzak begins with the Altalena incident of June 1948, the first armed dispute between David Ben-Gurion's Labor-led government and the right-wing paramilitary Irgun organization, led by future prime minister Menachem Begin. He then follows the legacy of conflict into the confrontations of the 1950s and the assassination of Dr. Rudolph Kastner, a World War II leader of the Hungarian Jews. Sprinzak shows how the 1967 Six-Day War -- Israel's greatest victory ever -- reopened, paradoxically, the great rift between the left and the right over the borders of Israel, inspiring such agitators as Meir Kahane, who founded the Jewish Defense League in the United States and the Kach party in Israel, and the Orthodox rabbis of Gush Emunim. Finally, Sprinzak reveals how the militancy of Israel's religious right has grown more fierce since the signing of the Oslo accords, reaching its peak in the 1994 Hebron massacre and the Rabin assassination the following year. In spite of its somber subject, Brother Against Brother is not a pessimistic book. Sprinzak does not think that there is danger of domestic civil war in Israel, and is convinced that the traumatic assassination of Yitzhak Rabin has had a restraining influence on most Israelis, including the radical right. In addition to focusing on the roots of Israeli violence, he identifies the powerful psycho-political mechanisms of Israeli restraint. Sprinzak believes, in fact, that Israelis are not violent people, and that had other Western nations faced Israel's external and internal challenges, their streets would have been flooded with blood. The book's underlying assumption (and hope) is that when peace between Israelis and Arabs is reached and the great debate over the borders of the nation is finally laid to rest, Israeli political violence will decline dramatically. Brother Against Brother offers a historical perspective that is too often lacking in day-to-day political analysis, and opens a new chapter in our understanding of one of the world's most fascinating nations.

What people are saying - Write a review

BROTHER AGAINST BROTHER: Violence and Extremism in Israeli Politics from Altalena to the Rabin Assassination

User Review  - Kirkus

The 1995 assassination of Yitzhak Rabin didn't happen "out of tire blue," according to this extremely well researched and written study. Sprinzhak (political Sscience/Hebrew Univ.; The Ascendance of ... Read full review


Crisis at Year One
The Eruption of Past Hatreds
The Case of Haredi Violence
Rebellion in the Periphery
Gush Emunim
The Crisis of the Israeli Radical Right
Jews Who Kill? Some Afterthoughts

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (1999)

Ehud Sprinzak is professor of political science at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and a popular radio and television commentator. He has written extensively on extremism, terrorism, and religious fundamentalism in Israel and the Middle East, and this is his fifth book. Sprinzak has contributed articles to the world's leading newspapers and magazines, including The New York Times, The Washington Post, Foreign Affairs, and Foreign Policy. He lives with his family in Jerusalem.

Bibliographic information