EXHIBIT VI Seat-mile and passenger-mile operating expenses-intercity common carriers of passengers, 1959 1 Includes ICC accounts: "Maintenance of equipment," "Transportation-rail line," ? Includes CAB account groups: "Flying operations" and "Direct maintenance." 3 Includes ICC account groups: "Equipment maintenance and garage expense," Includes ICC account groups: "Station expense," "Traffic and advertising expense," "Fixed charges and contingent interest" allocated to passenger service by train-miles. passenger service has been used by the Civil Aeronautics Board in regulatory proceed- 10 Scheduled passenger service only. 11 Includes only bus-miles in regular route intercity passenger service. Sources: Rail and bus. Interstate Commerce Commission, Transport Statistics in the Note on distribution of expenses.-The above distribution of expenses is not an accurate reflection of fixed and variable costs. It is based on the account groups used by regulatory agencies and differs from carrier to carrier. A much more accurate distribution from "Passengers and Profits," by Transportation Facts, Inc., appears below. The detailed accounts of each carrier (for 1955) were reclassified on a uniform basis for this purpose. Note on estimate of profits.-Due to lack of comparable data for rate bases and the wide disparity of capital turnover, rates of return on investment could not be used for a meaningful intermodal comparison. The chosen operating ratio, 93 percent after taxes and charges, is illustrative only. It has been used as a test by several regulators and is comparable to the earnings of the better managed air and bus lines in good years. EXHIBIT VII (PT. 1) Private auto operating expense per mile and passenger-mile 4 Basis for depreciation: 10-year average life. Reflects low first cost of contract purchase and average use in excess of 5 to 10 years varying with agency. AAA increases depreciation 1.8 cents per mile for annual operation over 18,000 miles. Sources: American Automobile Association, annual pamphlet "Your Driving Costs," prepared by Runzheimer & Co., Chicago, Ill., based on 1960 Chevrolet Bel-Air V-8 sedan. Bureau of Public Roads, staff study presented before highway research board Jan. 9-13, 1961. This is a revision of an article in Public Roads, June 1951. Data is for actual average life (10 years) experience of Big 3 4-door sedan. General Services Administration, Annual Motor Vehicle Report Fiscal Year 1959. These costs are for Government-owned sedans operated in fleets under a variety of annual mileages. Wall Street Journal, article of Aug. 23, 1960, comparing operating expenses of compact and full-size autos. Illustrations based on 1960 Ford Falcon and full-size Ford V-8. EXHIBIT VII (PT. 2) Private airplane operating expense of selected airplanes used for intercity 1 These prices include "standard" equipment. Due to wide variety of optional equipment many aircraft cost more or less than these prices. These aircraft have a total of 4 seats and are costed here without professional pilots. This assumes that business users will have necessary pilot training. Includes reserve for engine overhaul and pilot's overnight expenses. Most recent FAA survey shows annual average hours of use to be less than 300. Source: Basic data furnished by National Business Aircraft Association. EXHIBIT VIII Corporate financial results, common carriers of passengers, 1940–59 1 These profits come from railroad freight. Passenger service produced an operating loss in each of these years. The trend and stability of these profits are affected of course by the passenger deficit. Includes class II and III carriers. Not available. NOTE. Variation from average profit or loss is a measure of the relative stability of net earnings. Large changes from one year to the next indicate that the factors producing net earnings are difficult to control or exert great leverage on the financial result. The buslines are the most stable earners and airlines the least stable earners presented here. Sources: Same as table VI and in addition: Association of American Railroads, Railroad Transportation 1921-57; Air Transport Association of America, Air Transport Facts and Figures-Annual; National Association of Motorbus Owners, Bus Facts Annual. |