Hospitality as Holiness: Christian Witness Amid Moral DiversityWe live amid increasing ethical plurality and fragmentation while at the same time more and more questions of moral gravity confront us. Some of these questions are new, such as those around human cloning and genetics. Other questions that were previously settled have re-emerged, such as those around the place of religion in politics. Responses to such questions are diverse, numerous and often vehemently contested. Hospitality as Holiness seeks to address the underlying question facing the church within contemporary moral debates: how should Christians relate to their neighbours when ethical disputes arise? The problems the book examines centre on what the nature and basis of Christian moral thought and action is, and in the contemporary context, whether moral disputes may be resolved with those who do not share the same framework as Christians. Bretherton establishes a model - that of hospitality - for how Christians and non-Christians can relate to each other amid moral diversity. relationship between reason, tradition, natural law and revelation in theology, and more specifically to those engaged with questions about plurality, tolerance and ethical conflict in Christian ethics and medical ethics. |
Contents
Introduction | 1 |
THE PROBLEM OF MORAL PLURALITY | 7 |
Alasdair MacIntyres diagnosis of the contemporary context | 9 |
Virtue tradition and the recovery of moral reason | 17 |
Truth Thomism and discerning the moral order | 20 |
Natural law and the conditions for free and just relations | 25 |
Incommensurability and the resolution of moral disputes | 26 |
Summary | 30 |
Local politics and resisting modernity | 96 |
MacIntyres conception of relations between Christians and nonChristians | 99 |
Ecclesiology and resolving ethical disputes | 101 |
Eschatology and the nature of Christian distinctiveness | 110 |
Summary | 115 |
The practice of hospitality | 121 |
Hospitality and the shape of relations between Christians and their neighbours | 126 |
A theologically specified account of hospitality | 128 |
Germain Grisez and the shared rationality of all moral traditions | 34 |
Grisez and the new natural law account of ethics | 36 |
Grisez and MacIntyre compared | 39 |
The challenges Grisez poses to MacIntyre | 47 |
A critique of Grisez and the new natural law theory | 51 |
Summary | 56 |
Oliver ODonovan and the distinctiveness of Christian ethics | 61 |
ODonovans evangelical ethics | 64 |
ODonovan and MacIntyre compared | 69 |
Ad hoc commensurability or a clash of traditions? | 74 |
MacIntyres openness to theological specification | 80 |
Incommensurability and the resolution of moral disputes revisited | 87 |
THE NATURE AND SHAPE OF CHRISTIAN HOSPITALITY | 93 |
Local politics ecclesiology and resisting modernity | 95 |
Hospitality and tolerance contrasted | 147 |
Summary | 150 |
Hospitality hospice care and euthanasia a case study in negotiating moral diversity | 160 |
Defining euthanasia | 161 |
The practice of medicine and euthanasia | 165 |
Philosophical defences of euthanasia | 168 |
Relating autonomy death and suffering within a theological account of good care | 172 |
MacIntyres response to the care we owe the sufferingdying | 178 |
Grisezs understanding of the care we owe the sufferingdying | 180 |
Hospice care as an embodiment of Christian hospitality | 183 |
Conclusion | 196 |
199 | |
211 | |
Other editions - View all
Hospitality as Holiness: Christian Witness Amid Moral Diversity Luke Bretherton Limited preview - 2010 |
Hospitality as Holiness: Christian Witness Amid Moral Diversity Luke Bretherton Limited preview - 2017 |
Hospitality As Holiness: Christian Witness Amid Moral Diversity Luke Bretherton No preview available - 2017 |
Common terms and phrases
accept according action approach argues argument assessment authority basic basis bear becomes Cambridge central Christ Christian Ethics Christians and non-Christians church claim conception constitutes contemporary contrast creation critical critique culture death debate dependent determining distinct effect embodied enables engage eschatological established ethical disputes ethics euthanasia example faith feast freedom given gives God's Grisez ground Hauerwas Holy hospitality human Ibid incommensurability individual involves issue Jesus Jesus Christ John justice kind knowledge liberalism live London MacIntyre MacIntyre's means medicine moral natural law neighbours notes O'Donovan participate particular patient patterns person Philosophical political possible practice present principles problem question rational reality relations relationship religion requires resolve response seek shape share social social practices society specific Spirit stranger suffering suffering-dying theological theory thought tolerance tradition true truth understanding virtues witness