THE

MANITOBA REPORTS

VOLUME XXXII.

CONTAINING

REPORTS OF GASES

DECIDED IN

THE COURT OF KING'S BENGH

AND

GOURT OF APPEAL

FOR MANITOBA

REPORTER:

B. E. CHAFFEY, ESQ.

PUBLISHED BY, AND UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF, THE
LAW SOCIETY OF MANITOBA

BURROUGHS & Co., LIMITED

CALGARY, ALBERTA

1923

COPYRIGHT, CANADA, 1923

BY

THE LAW SOCIETY OF MANITOBA

352537

JUDGES

OF THE

COURT OF APPEAL

DURING THE PERIOD OF THESE REPORTS

HON. WILLIAM EGERTON PERDUE, C.J.M.
HON. JOHN Donald Cameron, J.A.
(Died 26th March, 1923.)

HON. CHARLEs Percy FullERTON, J.A.
HON. ROBERT MAXWELL DENNISTOUN, J.A.

HON. THOMAS LLEWELLYN METCALFE, J.A.

(Appointed 3rd October, 1921, died 2nd April, 1922.)

HON. JAMES Emile Pierre PRENDERGAST, J.A. (Appointed 1st May, 1922.)

HON. WALTER HARLEY TRUEMAN, J.A. (Appointed 14th April, 1923.)

Attorneys-General

HON. THOMAS H. JOHNSON, K.C.

HON. ROBERT JACOB

(Appointed 6th June, 1922.)

HON. RICHARD W. CRAIG, K.C.

(Appointed 8th August, 1922.)