CASES OVERRULED, DOUBTED AND DENIED.

!

Allen v. Merchants' Bank (22 Wend. 215), denied; Bank of Louisville v. First
Nat. Bank of Knoxville (8 Baxt. 101), 694.

Arthur v. Bank (9 Sm. & Marsh. 394), denied; Gooch v. McGee (83 N. C. 59),
562.

Austin v. Manchester, Sheffield & Lincolnshire Ry. Co. (10 C. B. 454; 16 Q. B.
600), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 18û), 750.
Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. v. Rathbone (1 W. Va. 87), overruled; Maslin v.
Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 758.

Bigler v. N. Y. Cent. Ins. Co. (22 N. Y. 402), denied; Firemen's Ins. Co. of
Dayton v. Holt (35 Ohio St. 189), 603.

Bissell v. N. Y. Cent. R. R. Co. (25 N. Y. 442), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore
Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 753.

Carpenter v. Providence Ins. Co. (16 Pet. 495), denied; Firemen's Ins. Co. of
Dayton v. Holt (35 Ohio St. 189), 603.

Caw v. Lancashire & Yorkshire Ry. Co. (7 Exch. 707), denied ; Maslin v. Balti-
more & Ohio R. R. Co. (15 W. Va. 180), 750.

Chippendale v. Lancashire & North River Ry. Co. (21 L. J. [N 8.] Q. B. 22), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 750.

Cragin v. N. Y. Cent. R. R. Co. (51 N. Y. 61; 10 Am. Rep. 559), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 754.

County of Dane v. Smith (13 Wis. 585), denied; Wayne County v. Waller (90 Penn. St. 99), 638.

Evans v. Rosser (2 Hem. & M. 190), denied; Stilwell v. Knapper (69 Ind. 558),
252, 253.

Grant v. Norway (2 Eng. L. & Eq. 337), denied; Sioux City, etc., R. R. Co. v.
First Nat. Bk. of Fremont (10 Neb. 556), 492.

Great North. Ry. Co. v. Morrille (21 L. J. [N. S.] Q. B. 319), denied; Maslin v.
Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 750.

Hall v. Washington County (2 Green, 473), denied; Wayne County v.
Waller (90 Penn. St. 99), 638.

Harper v Hampton (1 Harr. & J. 709), denied; McClure v. Heming (70 Mo.
18), 407

Hinton v. Dibbin (2 Q. B. 646), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co.
(14 W. Va. 180), 750.

Hubberstay v. Ward (18 Ad. & Ell. 551), denled; Sioux City, etc., R. R. Co. v.
First Nat. Bk. of Fremont (10 Neb. 556), 492.

Hughes v. Great Western Ry. Co. (14 C. B. 527), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore
& Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 750.

VOL. XXXV — E

xxxiv CASES OVERRULED, DOUBTED AND DENIED.

Jacobs v. Eq. Ins. Co. (19 N. C. 250), denied; Firemen's Ins. Co. of Dayton v. Holt (35 Ohio St. 189), 603.

Jackson v. Brookins (5 Hun, 530), denied; Kirchner v. Myers (35 Ohio St. 85), 600.

Levi v. Earl (30 Ohio St. 147), overruled; Williams v. Urmston (35 Ohio St. 296), 613, 617.

Lowber v. Smith (7 Barr. 381), doubted; Green v. Disbrow (79 N. Y. 1), 504. McMahon v. N. Y. & Erie R. R. Co. (20 N. Y. 463), denied; Norton v. Gale (95 III. 533), 176.

Magnin v. Dinsmore (56 N. Y. 168), denied: Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio B. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 754.

Martin v. Funk (75 N. Y. 134; 31 Am. Rep. 446), denied in part; Gerrish v. New Bedford Inst. for Savings (128 Mass. 159), 370.

Packard v. Van Schoick (58 Ill. 79,, overruled; Norton v. Gale (95 Ill. 538), 177.

People v. Organ (27 Ill. 29), overruled; City of Chicago v. Gage (95 Ill. 598), 183, 186.

Perkins v. Elliott (23 N. J. Eq. 526), denied; Williams v. Urmston (35 Ohio St. 296), 612.

Perkins v. N. Y. Cent. R. R. Co. (24 N. Y. 181), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 753.

Perrine v. Firemen's Ins. Co. (22 Ala, 575), doubted; White's Adm'r v. Life Association of America (63 Ala. 419), 53.

Baltimore

Peters v. Newkirk (6 Cow. 103), denied; Norton v. Gale (95 Ill. 533), 176.
Poucher v. N. Y. Cent. R. R. Co. (49 N. Y. 263), denied; Maslin v.
& Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 754.

Quain v. Russell (8 Hun, 319), denied; Kirchner v. Myers (35 Ohio St. 85), 600.

Rafferty v. Buckman (46 Iowa, 195), denied; Kirchner v. Myers (35 Ohio St. 85), 600.

Rice v. Railroad (32 Ohio St. 380), overruled; Williams v. Urmston (35 Ohio St. 296), 617.

Schooner Freeman v. Buckingham (18 How. 182), denied, Sioux City, etc., R. R. Co. v. First Nat. Bk. of Fremont (10 Neb. 556), 492.

Schroeder v. Crawford (94 Ill. 357; 34 Am. Rep. 236), denied; Kirchner v. Myers (35 Ohio St. 85), 600.

Schumcker v. Siebert (18 Kans. 104; 26 Am. Rep. 765), denied; Browne v. Browne (17 Fla. 607), 105.

Shaw v. York & North Midland Ry. Co. (13 Q. B. 347), denied; Maslin v. Bal timore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 750.

Slim v. Great Northern Ry. Co. (14 C. B. 647), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 750.

State v. Rives (5 Ind. 297), overruled; Gooch v. McGee (83 N. C. 59), 562, 563. Steers v. Liverpool, N. Y. & Phila. Steamship Co. (57 N. Y. 1; 15 Am. Rep. 543), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 754. Sweet v. Barney (23 N.Y. 335), doubted; Howard v. Steamship Co. (83 N. C 158), 573.

CASES OVERRULED, DOUBTED AND DENIED. XXXV

Town of South Ottawa v. Foster (20 III. 296), overruled; Hollenbeck v. Winnebago County (95 Ill. 148), 156.

Wells v. N. Y. Cent. R. R. Co. (26 Barb. 641; 24 N. Y. 181), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 753.

Wyld v. Pickford (8 M. & W. 443), denied; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R, R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 750.

York, Newcastle & Berwick Ry. Co. v. Crisp (14 C. B. 527), denied ; Maslin v. Baltimore & Ohio R. R. Co. (14 W. Va. 180), 750.