and cleared them from any blame or dishonour, to the shame of their adversaries. But by reason of the great alterations in the State, he was detained longer then was expected; and afterwards ten pounds of it, lest it might lie too heavy upon his wife and children. But he must either get new sureties for the [his] behaviour till the next generall Court, or such time as hee departed the Government, or lie in prison till hee could: now hee knowing his outragious passions which hee could not restraine, procured sureties, but immediately left Plimouth and went to Roade Island." Hypocrisie Vnmasked, *67. In 1669 Gorton took exception to the statements made by Morton and in a lengthy letter characteristically gave his own rendering of the facts. "If you had recorded truly you should haue made report of Plimouths dealing with me had bin their threatening of a widow one Ellin Aldridge whom they said they would send out of the Collony as a vacabond by some of your inferiour officers, when as nothing was laid to her charge, only it was whispered priuatly that she had smiled in your congregation, whervpon it may be the Church grew iealous that she did not well like your Doctrine and graue pollished Church order, And she hauing bin a woman of good report in England and newly come ouer, being carefull of her credit she fled into the woods to escape the shame which was threatened to be put upon her, there remaining seuerall dayes and nights, at the least part of the nights and absented her selfe againe before people stirred in the morning; my speaking on her behalfe (she being then my wiues servant) was the ocation that Plimouths government tooke to deale with me, whervpon they called me to a Court more priuatly held to examine me, and one of them inlarging vpon a point agravating the matter more then it deserued, I said he spake hyperbollically whervpon they asked your Elder [Brewster] then present, what was the meaning of that word, and he was pleased to expound it that I told the magistrate that he lyed; and this was the dealing with me, and accordingly they gaue their owne constructions of what I spake afterwards, only in your Court more publique the foreman of your jury (your Elders son Jonathan Brewster) befriended me so much as to moue the Court that I should not speake in my owne behalfe at all, and there was no Atourney to be had in those dayes that I knew of. . . . "In the time of these agitations Mr. Smith tooke offence at me whether of himselfe or instigated I know not, neither know I any ocation I gaue him, vnlesse it was because his ancient wife and others of his family frequented mine vsually morning and euening in the time of family exercises, and so did a religious maid liuing then with your teacher Mr. Reyner, mistress Smith often expressing her selfe how glad she was that she could come into a family where her spirit was refreshed in the ordinances of god as in former dayes which she said was much decayed and allmost worne out of religion since she came to Plimouth; In this offence taken by Mr. Smith he applied himselfe to the gouernment of Plimouth for help to breake his couenant made with my selfe, I hauing hired one part of his house for the terme of foure whole yeares, whervpon fell into other imployments their, so as he hath now bene absente I was perswaded to put the matter to arbitterment the men were apointed, my Co. nothing to issue the matter, neither could I John Cooke. procure my writings againe vnto this day, any, but the Court proceeded to fine and banishment, together with sentence giuen 1 Winslow had sailed from Boston October, 1646, and four years later was on the joint board of "The Committee for Sequestration and Advancement of Money and for compounding with Delinquents." See Dictionary of National Biography. 1 The following is a list of the ministers settled at New Plymouth and its dependencies before 1648, with the periods of service so far as known: New Plymouth: Ralph Smith (1629 Chauncy (1638-1641). ); John Reyner (1636-1654); Charles Scituate: John Lothrop (1635-1639); Charles Chauncy (1641-1654). Sandwich: William Leverich (1639-1653). Taunton: William Hooke (1639-1644); Nicholas Street (1639-1659). Yarmouth: Marmaduke Matthews (1639-1643); John Miller (1643-1660). |