First Nations? Second Thoughts

Front Cover
McGill-Queen's Press - MQUP, 2000 - History - 245 pages
Controversial and thought-provoking, Tom Flanagan's First Nations? Second Thoughts dissects the prevailing orthodoxy that determines public policy towards Canada's Aboriginal peoples. Flanagan argues that this orthodoxy enriches and empowers a small elite of activists, politicians, administrators, middlemen, and well-connected entrepreneurs, while bringing further misery to the very people it is supposed to help. Over the last thirty years Canadian policy on Aboriginal issues has come to be dominated by an ideology that sees Aboriginal peoples as "nations" entitled to specific rights. Indians and Inuit now enjoy a cornucopia of legal privileges, including rights to self-government beyond federal and provincial jurisdiction, immunity from taxation, court decisions reopening treaty issues settled long ago, the right to hunt and fish without legal limits, and free housing, education, and medical care as well as other economic benefits. Underpinning these privileges is what Flanagan describes as Aboriginal orthodoxy - a set of beliefs that hold that prior residence in North America is an entitlement to special treatment; that Aboriginal peoples are part of sovereign nations endowed with an inherent right to self-government; that Aboriginals must have collective rather than individual property rights; that all treaties must be renegotiated on a "nation-to-nation" basis; and that Native people should be encouraged to build prosperous "Aboriginal economies" through money, land, and natural resources transferred from other Canadians. In First Nations? Second Thoughts Flanagan combines conceptual analysis with historical and empirical information to show that the Aboriginal orthodoxy is both unworkable and ultimately destructive to the people it is supposed to help.

What people are saying - Write a review

We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.


1 The Aboriginal Orthodoxy
2 We Were Here First
3 What Ever Happened to Civilization?
4 The Fiction of Aboriginal Sovereignty
5 Bands Tribes or Nations?
6 The Inherent Problems of Aboriginal SelfGovernment
7 In Search of Property
8 Treaties Agreements and Land Surrenders
9 Making a Living
10 This Octagon Is a Stop Sign
11 Update 2008

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2000)

THOMAS FLANAGAN is a professor in the Department of Political Science, University of Calgary, author of Waiting for the Wave: The Reform Party and Preston Manning, and co-editor of The Collected Writings of Louis Riel.

Bibliographic information