Court of Appeals and the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court.

JOSEPH A. LAWSON, REPORTER.

VOLUME LXXVII.

1913

J. B. LYON COMPANY, PUBLISHERS,

ALBANY, N. Y.

OT

Ho

Entered according to act of Congress, in the year one thousand nine hundred

and thirteen,

Bx MITCHELL MAY, SECRETARY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK,

in trust for the benefit of the People of the said State in the office of the Librarian

of Congress, at Washington, D. C.

Justices of The Supreme Court OTHER THAN THOSE DESIGNATED TO CONSTITUTE

THE APPELLATE DIVISION.

FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT.
Hon. EDWARD B. AMEND,

Hon. JAMES W. GERARD,
NATHAN BIJUR,*

LEONARD A. GIEGERICH,
HENRY BISCHOFF,

JOHN W. GOFF,
JAMES A. BLANCHARD,

SAMUEL GREENBAUM,
JOHN J. BRADY,

CHARLES L. GUY,
DANIEL P. COHALAN,

PETER A. HENDRICK,
VERNON M. DAVIS,

HENRY D. HOTCHKISS,
CHARLES W. DAYTON,

IRVING LEHMAN,*
JOHN J. DELANY,

EDWARD E. MCCALL,
P. HENRY DUGR0,

JOSEPH E. NEWBURGER,
MITCHELL L. ERLANGER,

ALFRED R. PAGE,
JAMES FITZGERALD,

FRANCIS K. PENDLETON,
JOHN FORD,

M. WARLEY PLATZEK,
EDWARD J. GAVEGAN,

SAMUEL SEABURY. *

44

66

64

66

SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT.

64

Hon. JOSEPH ASPINALL,

Ilon. ISAAC M. KAPPER,
RUSSELL BENEDICT,

CHARLES H. KELBY,
ABEL E. BLACKMAR,

WILLIAM J. KELLY,
WILLIAM J. CARR,

SAMUEL T. MADDOX,
LESTER W. CLARK,

JOSIAH T. MAREAN,
FREDERICK E. CRANE,

HARRINGTON PUTNAM,
GARRET J. GARRETSON.

TOWNSEND SCUDDER,
WALTER H. JAYCOX,

LUKE D. STAPLETON,
Hon. JAMES C. VAN SICLEN.

THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT. Hon. ALDEN CHESTER,

Hon. WESLEY O. HOWARD, A. V. S. COCHRANE,

WILLIAM P. RUDD.

FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT.
Hon. HENRY T. KELLOGG,

Hon. CHARLES C. VAN KIRK,
Hon. EDWARD C. WHITMYER.

FIFTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT.
Hon. WILLIAM S. ANDREWS, Hon. EDGAR C. EMERSON,
PASCAL C. J. DE ANGELIS,

IRVING G. HUBBS,
IRVING R. DEVENDORF,

EDGAR S. K. MERRELL,

66

SIXTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT.
Hon. ALBERT F. GLADDING,

Hon. RANDOLPH HORTON,
Hon. ALBERT H. SEWELL.

Hon. GEORGE A. BENTON

Hon. SAMUEL N. SAWYER,
WILLIAM W. CLARK,

ARTHUR E. SUTHERLAND.

EIGHTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT.
Hon, CHARLES H. BROWN,

Hon. LOUIS W. MARCUS,
EDWARD K. EMERY,

CHARLES A. POOLEY,
WARREN B. HOOKER,

CUTHBERT W. POUND.
JOHN S. LAMBERT,

CHARLES B. WHEELER.

66

NINTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT.
Hon. MARTIN J. KEOGH,

Hon. JOSEPH MORSCHAUSER,
ISAAC N. MILLS,

ARTHUR S. TOMPKINS.

JUSTICES OF THE CITY COURT OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK.
Hon, EDWARD F. 0'DWYER, CH, J., Hon. EDWARD B. LA FETRA,
FRANCIS B. DELEHANTY,

RICHARD T. LYNCH,
THOMAS F. DONNELLY,

JOIN V. MCAVOY,
ALEXANDER FINELITE,

PETER SCHMUCK
JOSEPH I. GREEN,

RICHARD H. SMITH.

JUDGES OF THE COURT OF GENERAL SESSIONS OF THE

PEACE OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK.
Hon. THOMAS C. T. CRAIN,

Hon. JOSEPH F. MULQUEEN,
WARREN W. FOSTER,

THOMAS C. O'SULLIVAN,
JAMES T. MALONE,

06