Page images
PDF
EPUB
[graphic]

Mercury vapor lighting on softball field at Burbank, California, with 22,400 watts. Note clear light on playing field and lack of spread beyond.

Outdoor Recreational Lighting

E

Consider it an investment, not an expense

XTENDED HOURS of use resulting from the lighting of outdoor areas are readily seen as a benefit. Equally important, however, is the benefit gained by providing opportunity and incentive for adult participation at convenient hours.

It could almost be said that any unlighted outdoor facility for recreation is but half effective in its service to the community. It could certainly be said that outdoor areas designed and installed without careful evaluation of the extended usehours gained from lighting would be very poor planning indeed.

BASIC FACTORS

There are three basic elements in deciding on outdoor lighting. First would be the measure of light required to service the activity or activities for which the area is designed; second, the type and quality of installation; and third, the cost of maintenance. In the first instance, one can use the NEMA (National Electric Manufacturers Association) standard or, by comparative measurement of existing installations,

by DEWEY R. KRUCKEBERG Superintendent, Parks and Recreational Department Burbank, California

set up one's own standard; secondly, the selection of type would be a choice of incandescent or mercury vapor lighting, and quality a matter of wood or steel poles with overhead or underground wiring; and thirdly, the maintenance cost would, obviously, be a matter of calculation after the choice has been established.

As to the values of the NEMA standards, there is a question in regard to their adaptability to recreational lighting at the public agency level-mostly from the angle of cost. More often than not a good job of lighting is a matter of distribution rather than of volume. One contemplating recreational lighting should appraise the objective carefully before accepting any precise and predetermined formula.

OBJECTIVE

In establishing an objective, it is fairly obvious that the first calculation would be a relation of usage to cost, i.e., number of participanthours to be gained and number of persons who will use them. Next, it must be determined how important these hours are to the community or

area it is to serve. Further, the cos per participant-hour must be justifie in comparison to other services.

The social and physical makeup o the community or area will largely govern these calculations. Its "tone in terms of industrial, agricultural or residential development, per capita wealth, proximity to other facilities of similar nature, population densi ties, and accessibility will be the main factors for evaluation.

Another important element in planning lighted areas-and it cannot be overemphasized-is multiplicity of uses. As an example, it may be difficult to justify the lighting of a baseball field as such, yet when it is designed to accommodate softball, football, track, carnivals, pageantry, and other large group activity, it becomes a fairly simple matter by reason of its diverse appeal to the whole community or area. Any compromise upon multiple-use design will build resistance in almost exact ratio to the degree of such compromise and, besides, it is very poor planning from the investment angle.

(Concluded on page 14)

[ocr errors][merged small]
[graphic]

SECOUR CATALOG IN

SWEETS FRED MEDART PRODUCTS, INC..3544 DE KALB ST. LOUIS 18, MO.

[ocr errors]

13

Outdoor Lighting

(Continued from page 12)

CHOOSING TYPE

Quality as well as intensity of light
has been greatly improved with little
more than one-third of the energy
consumed. In other words, a highly
improved lighting is available at one-
third the cost of electricity. A fur-
ther consideration, from the operat-
ing cost viewpoint, is the greatly
extended lamp life gained in the
mercury vapor type of installation,
experience having demonstrated a
350-hour useful intensity for the in-
candescent type and an estimated
9,000 hours for the mercury vapor.

COST OF INSTALLATION

Initial cost for installation of mer-

cury vapor lighting is appreciably

more than the incandescent, due pri-

marily to the cost of the lamp and the

necessity for ballasting each unit.

The Burbank installation, being the

first of its kind, cost just under three

times that of standard incandescent

type due, naturally, to the experi-

mental design, layout, and fabrica-

tion work which attends such a revo-

lutionary change. At present market,

it would be fair to estimate the cost

of mercury vapor at double that of

incandescent, yet this increase in ini-

tial outlay will easily be liquidated in

a five-year period by the saving in

energy consumption and lamp re-

placement.

In any evaluation of recreational

lighting, particularly in the case of
active sports areas, volume of output
does not necessarily mean adequacy.
The relative efficiencies should be
rated in degrees of glare, dispersal,
and location rather than solely upon
foot-candles on the ground-or, in
other words, effective use of mini-
mums rather than reliance upon
maximums. The ultimate in lighting
a recreational area is gained when
the objective is permeation rather
than projection, and it is here that
the mercury vapor lamp with color
correction far surpasses the incan-
descent or filament type of lamp.

DESIGN AND LAYOUT

In the area of design and layout,

the factors of height and location of

light poles will largely determine the

effectiveness of the installation, both

in terms of penetration and spread;

and, of course, the safety of the play-

ers is also a prime consideration. The

relationship of numbers of light units

to angles of projection or, in other

words, the placement of wide, medi-

um, and narrow beam types of re-

flectors, is a close second in import-

ance. It often makes the difference

between an adequate job with a mini-

mum of light units and "loading"

with additional light units to gain

an equal result. A predetermined base.

of light output required for a given

use can be established, and to in-

crease it by volume alone "just to

be sure" is expensive in both installa-

tion and operating cost. The qual-

ity of light is not measured solely by

quantity of output but is more often

a matter of distribution.

AMORTIZING COST

Amortizing the cost of lighting
services through fee charges is a
practice which has become quite com-
mon and meets with little resistance
from the user. It is, naturally, a mat-
ter for each community or area to
decide the amount of such charges at
policy level. Amortization of invest-
ment, depreciation, and maintenance.
costs will, in most cases, produce a
prohibitive fee insofar as the aver-
age user is concerned. A good prac-
tical base for calculation of fee
charges is from the actual mainte-
nance cost which would be inclusive
of electrical energy consumed, lamp

replacement, and conditioning of re-
flectors and poles. In a high percent-
age of instances, the capital invest-
ment and depreciation items can be
legitimately charged against increase
of recreational opportunity.

In establishing hourly rates from
an actual cost of maintenance level,
the prevailing lighting rate per kilo-
watt hour (1,000 watts for one hour)
will be a firm figure, to which an esti-
mated figure must be added for lamp
replacement and maintenance. This
latter figure will vary slightly ac-
cording to the region in which it
applies. Adding 25 per cent of the
kilowatt hour rate to cover lamp re-
placement and maintenance will prove
adequate in most cases where incan-
descent type of lighting is used. The
mercury vapor type of lighting is too
new to estimate with accuracy, yet it
seems fairly certain the same ratio
will hold, the economy being in the
lowered consumption for an equiva-
lent in light output and greatly ex-
tended lamp life.

As an example, assuming the base

rate of two cents per kilowatt hour

for easy calculation, the equation

would produce a use charge of $1.50

per hour for the 60 kilowatts con-

sidered minimum for lighting a

standard softball field with the con-

ventional incandescent type of lamp.

Using the mercury vapor type of

lamp, with 22.5 kilowatts consumed

in producing an equivalent light out-

put of a much higher quality, this

use charge could be lowered to 56.25

cents per hour.

As a further assumption, should
the contracting agency desire to
amortize the increased cost of the
mercury vapor installation, an in-
vestment or depreciation charge of
roughly 30 per cent could be added
and still provide a better light at one-
half the cost to the user.

FUNCTIONAL PART OF DESIGN

In conclusion, it should be stated

that it would be an exceptional case,
indeed, where lighting of a recre-
ational area would need justification.
The diversification of activities will
determine the types and kinds of il-
lumination best suited, and the plan-
ner who does not consider it as a
functional part of design is truly
planning in the dark. ★

[graphic]

HERE HAS BEEN, in recent

years, a realization of the importance of many aspects of health hitherto poorly understood and neglected. Multiple sclerosis is one of the conditions about which there was, until recently, little understanding. Except for those individuals who have had the tragic experience of personal exposure or have seen a friend or relative fall victim to this malady, few were familiar with the term or understood its implications.

Multiple sclerosis now afflicts approximately 250,000 persons in the United States. It tends to strike in the third and fourth decades of life. Needless to say, a disease as ravaging as multiple sclerosis affects and alters all of its victims' plans.

DESCRIPTION OF MS

In multiple sclerosis, for reasons which are not understood, changes take place in a curious, fatty substance called myelin, which appears to have approximately the same function for the nerve tracts of the brain and spinal cord that insulation has for electric wires. When the myelin "insulation" is damaged, the ability of the nerve tracts to transmit messages to and fro is altered. Since the brain and spinal cord dominate the control of virtually all functions of the body, multiple sclerosis may affect an individual in an infinite number of ways.

The clinical picture seen in multiple sclerosis is completely unpredictable and often very bizarre. Most common disturbances are those of vision, gait, bladder and bowel function, and the onset of tremors, which usually increase when motion is attempted and often cease when the individual is in a resting position.

[graphic][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][merged small][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][subsumed][merged small][subsumed]
« PreviousContinue »