The Tragedy of American Compassion

Front Cover
Regnery Publishing, Feb 1, 1994 - Social Science - 299 pages
11 Reviews
Can a man be content with a piece of bread and some change tossed his way from a passerby? Today's modern welfare state expects he can. Those who control the money in our society think that giving a dollar at the train station and then appropriating a billion dollars for federal housing can cure the ails of the homeless and the poor. But the crisis of the modern welfare state is more than a crisis of government. Private charities that dispense aid indiscriminately while ignoring the moral and spiritual needs of the poor are also to blame. Like animals in the zoo at feeding time, the needy are given a plate of food but rarely receive the love and time that only a person can give. Poverty fighters 100 years ago were more compassionate--in the literal meaning of "suffering with"--than many of us are now. They opened their own homes to deserted women and children. They offered employment to nomadic men who had abandoned hope and human contact. Most significantly, they made moral demands on recipients of aid. They saw family, work, freedom, and faith as central to our being, not as life-style options. No one was allowed to eat and run. Some kind of honest labor was required of those who needed food or a place to sleep in return. Woodyards next to homeless shelters were as common in the 1890's as liquor stores are in the 1990's. When an able bodied woman sought relief, she was given a seat in the "sewing room" and asked to work on garments given to the helpless poor. To begin where poverty fighters a century ago began, Marvin Olasky emphasizes seven ideas that recent welfare practice has put aside: affiliation, bonding, categorization, discernment, employment, freedom, and most importantly, belief in God. In the end, not much will be accomplished without a spiritual revival that transforms the everyday advice we give and receive, and the way we lead our lives. It's time we realized that there is only so much that public policy can do. That only a richness of spirit can battle a poverty of soul. The century-old question--does any given scheme of help...make great demands on men to give themselves to their brethren?--is still the right one to ask. Most of our 20th-century schemes have failed. It's time to learn from the warm hearts and hard heads of the 19th-century.
  

What people are saying - Write a review

User ratings

5 stars
6
4 stars
3
3 stars
1
2 stars
1
1 star
0

LibraryThing Review

User Review  - mrtall - LibraryThing

I cannot recall where I came across a reference to this book -- but I am very, very glad I did. Although this comprehensive and remarkably illuminating history of American charity and social service ... Read full review

Review: The Tragedy of American Compassion

User Review  - Ian - Goodreads

Essential history of American anti-poverty programs, their original religious inspiration and their present-day socialistic corruption. Read full review

Selected pages

Contents

THE EARLY AMERICAN MODEL OF COMPASSION
6
TURNING CITIES INTO COUNTRYSIDE
24
FIRST CHALLENGE TO THE CHARITY CONSENSUS
42
THE SOCIAL DARWINIST THREAT
60
PROVING SOCIAL DARWINISM WRONG
80
THE SEVEN MARKS OF COMPASSION
99
AND WHY NOT DO MORE?
116
EXCITEMENT OF A NEW CENTURY
134
SELLING NEW DEALS IN OLD WINESKINS
151
REVOLUTIONAND ITS HEARTBREAK
167
QUESTIONS OF THE 1970S AND 1980S
184
PUTTING COMPASSION INTO PRACTICE
200
APPLYING HISTORY
217
ENDNOTES
235
INDEX
291
Copyright

Common terms and phrases

References to this book

All Book Search results »

About the author (1994)

Marvin Olasky is Professor of Journalism at the University of Texas at Austin and a Senior Fellow at the Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Liberty. He is the author of more than a dozen books of history and policy analysis, and the editor of "World, " a weekly news magazine from a Christian perspective. He has been an adviser to George Bush since 1993.

Bibliographic information