Making the Implicit Explicit: Creating Performance Expectations for the DissertationDespite their and other stakeholders' consistent demand for excellence, doctoral programs have rarely, if ever, been assessed in terms of the quality of the dissertations departments produce. Yet dissertations provide the most powerful, objective measure of the success of a department's doctoral program. Indeed, assessment, when done properly, can help departments achieve excellence by providing insight into a program's strengths and weaknesses. This book and the groundbreaking study on which it is based is about making explicit to doctoral students the tacit "rules" for the assessment of the final of all final educational products--the dissertation. The purpose of defining performance expectations is to make them more transparent to graduate students while they are in the researching and writing phases, and thus to help them achieve to higher levels of accomplishment. Lovitts proposes the use of rubrics to clarify performance expectations--not to rate dissertations or individual components of dissertations to provide a summary score, but to facilitate formative assessment to support, not substitute for, the advising process. She provides the results of a study in which over 270 faculty from ten major disciplines--spanning the sciences, social sciences, and humanities--were asked to make explicit their implicit standards or criteria for evaluating dissertations. The book concludes with a summary of the practical and research implications for different stakeholders: faculty, departments, universities, disciplinary associations, accrediting organizations, and doctoral students themselves. The methods described can easily be adapted for the formative assessment of capstone courses, senior and master's theses, comprehensive exams, papers, and journal articles. |
Contents
JUDGING DISSERTATIONS 30 | 3 |
I | 9 |
ACHIEVING EXCELLENCE | 19 |
Copyright | |
31 other sections not shown
Other editions - View all
Making the Implicit Explicit: Creating Performance Expectations for the ... Barbara E. Lovitts No preview available - 2023 |
Making the Implicit Explicit: Creating Performance Expectations for the ... Barbara E. Lovitts No preview available - 2007 |
Common terms and phrases
acceptable dissertations advisor analysis analyzed answer approach argument asked assessment authentic performance biology chapter clear coherent Components concepts context creative critical degree demonstrate dents develop Different Quality disciplines discussion and conclusion dissertation committees dissertation see Table doctoral education doctoral students duction econometric economics engineering experience faculty noted faculty's felt field focus group faculty focus group participants going graduate students historiographic hypotheses ideas identifies important independent insight interesting interpretation Karel deLeeuw knowledge look mathematicians mathematics matrix ment methods original contribution outstanding dissertation outstanding literature review papers participant noted performance expectations Ph.D philosophy problem programs provides psychology published Quality levels question reader relevant rubrics sciences sertation shows significant contribution sociology sources standards Students who write synthesizes talk tation techniques theoretical theory there's thesis things thought tion topic ture typically Unacceptable understand universities written